Megan ([info]bunnikins) wrote,

Books, not by that Rowling person.

So, I read War for the Oaks, finally. People have been telling me for years this is a good book, and I always intended to read it, but it never quite happened; I'd pick it up, look at the blurb or one of several dreadful covers I've seen for it, and a little voice in my head would say "Noooo! Elves on motorcycles, run away quickly!". And I did. But then, last week I was at the City Library, and they had a trade paperback, with a cover not at all reminiscent of a Mercedes Lackey novel, so I borrowed it. And read it, and, even, really quite liked it. Not enough to go looking for other books by Emma Bull, but quite a lot. So there you go.


And now I'm reading Salt, by Adam Roberts. And not liking it a whole lot, but not disliking it enough to put it down, either. I have a funny relationship with this author, I never quite enjoy his books, but I can never quite remember afterwards what I didn't like about it, so I pick up the next one. This one is a fairly well written look at extreme culture shock, but the battle sequences are far too clinical to build any sense of actual chaos, and the characters are such non-people that I have a hard time caring which is which, making it hard to care about the individual storylines. I'm pretty sure this isn't what my complaint was with the last one of his I read, but I'm blowed if I can recall what was....


And in between the two, I re-read Neverwhere. Which, as always, was VERY VERY GOOD!


The End.

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 6 comments

[info]usuakari

July 25 2005, 16:20:08 UTC 6 years ago

I only read War for the Oaks a couple of months ago as well. Like you, I think I'd resisted reading anything that sounded that much like 'Shadowrun: The novel' (in the same way that Magician turned out to be the grandiose wish-fulfillment of Feist's Friday-night D&D games). I enjoyed it, but didn't think it was worth the hype. Given that it's a first novel (I think), I'm curious about what she's become as a writer since. Her collaboration with Steven Brust, Freedom and Necessity, was pretty darn good, but that may have been due to him rather than her. Hard to tell...

I think that Megan Lindholm and the ever-verbose Charles de Lint do urban fantasy better.

[info]bunnikins

July 26 2005, 02:05:01 UTC 6 years ago

Lindholm...well, I only really liked Wizard of the Pigeons. But that one, yeah, good stuff.

De Lint rocks my world, but it's all a bit soap opera like once you get to know all these characters, so it was refreshing to meet some new ones, so to speak. But I still want to live in Tamsin House someday...

[info]neefsck

July 25 2005, 23:13:25 UTC 6 years ago

And now I'm reading Salt, by Adam Roberts. And not liking it a whole lot, but not disliking it enough to put it down, either. I have a funny relationship with this author, I never quite enjoy his books, but I can never quite remember afterwards what I didn't like about it, so I pick up the next one.

Oh Yes.
I read..On a while back, and I felt it was just damn flat (no pun intended).
His books just dont seem to go anywhere..they just tend to ramble on, with no particular highs or lows.
At least thats how I feel about it..

[info]bunnikins

July 26 2005, 02:28:48 UTC 6 years ago

Yeah, I know what you mean about flat...I think I've read On, but I'm not sure because his books don't seem to stick in my memory at all....

[info]debauchee

July 26 2005, 00:14:57 UTC 6 years ago

I just read an Ian Irvine book. the story was good but the writing style was so fucking annoying. That means for me that i couldnt put it down because i was rather interested in the plot but his writing style drove me mental. catch 22.

[info]bunnikins

July 26 2005, 02:33:36 UTC 6 years ago

I hate that, when you'd really like to throttle the author by halfway through the book, but you can't stop reading because you want to know what happens!
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…